Numerical Modeling Studies of the
El Niño-Southern Oscillation

by Nathan J. Mantua

Ph D Dissertation, University of Washington
June, 1994


Chairpersons of the supervisory committee:
Professors David S. Battisti and Edward S. Sarachik
Department of Atmospheric Sciences, University of Washington

Abstract

Aspects of the El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) are investigated with numerical models of the tropical Pacific region. The topics addressed include: the relevance of the 'delayed oscillator theory' to the real world ENSO cycle; the cause for the aperiodic variability in the Zebiak-Cane (ZC) model's simulated ENSO cycle; the differences between the ZC and Battisti (B88) coupled ocean-atmosphere models; and the forecast skill of the B88 coupled ocean-atmosphere model.

The relevance of the delayed oscillator theory for ENSO is investigated by analyzing the output from a wind-driven hindcast of variability in a reduced gravity ocean model for the tropical Pacific basin. The interannual variability in the output from the hindcast simulation reproduces that found in observed tide-gauge data and is shown to be consistent with the delayed oscillator scenario for the evolution of individual warm and cold phases of the ENSO cycle. Output from coupled ocean-atmosphere models that contain a simulated ENSO cycle, along with that from a series of idealized cases, demonstrates that simple lag/lead correlations predicted by pure delayed oscillator theory are sensitive to the regularity of the ENSO cycle in the system being studied.

The aperiodic interannual variability in the standard ZC model is found to result from interactions between the mobile mode--a sub-annual, westward propagating unstable mode of air-sea interaction--and the interannual ENSO mode. The mobile mode is most active during the cold phases of the model ENSO due to asymmetries in the prescribed basic-state fields of sea surface temperature (SST) and zonal surface current, and the non-linearity in the subsurface temperature parameterization. The physics of the mobile mode is similar to that of a coupled, gravest-oceanic-Rossby mode. The cyclic nature of the ENSO mode, by itself well-described by the delayed oscillator theory, is interrupted by ocean disturbances produced by the mobile mode. The B88 coupled model behavior is dominated by an interannual ENSO mode and does not exhibit the mobile mode instability. The differing stability characteristics of the ZC and B88 coupled models result from dissimilarities in the parameter regimes in which the two models operate.

Forecasts of an index for ENSO variability are carried out with three different versions of the B88 coupled model. The best forecast skill is obtained from a model that operates in a parameter regime that is intermediate between that of the ZC and B88 models. Forecast skill is found to be sensitive to the strength of the thermocline/SST coupling.


corresponding author: Nathan Mantua, University of Washington, JISAO, Box 354235, Seattle, WA 98195-4235.

email:

mantua@atmos.washington.edu

url http://www.atmos.washington.edu/~mantua/abst.DISSERTATION.html