UPDATE, June 3, 2016: Comments on Millenium Bulk Terminals-Longview Draft EIS
The State of Washington has released its draft EIS (DEIS) for this project. It is available here:
Because of our expertise and research on PM and coal dust around Washington State I am making technical comments on the EIS. I want to be clear that my comments are a technical assessment of the DEIS and do not constitute an opinion on the merits of the project one way or the other. You can read my comments on the DEIS here:
UPDATE, November 16, 2015: New peer-reviewed article
Diesel particulate matter and coal dust from trains in the Columbia River Gorge, Washington State, USA by Daniel Jaffe, Justin Putz, Greg Hof, Gordon Hof, Jonathan Hee, Dee Ann Lommers-Johnson, Francisco Gabela, Juliane L. Fry, Benjamin Ayres, Makoto Kelp and Madison Minsk
This article has been published in the journal Atmospheric Pollution Research. The full article and supplemental video files can be accessed here:
What is Apollo?
Apollo is research project studying the air quality implications of coal and diesel trains. Our research focused on answering the question: Do coal and diesel trains cause unhealthy air? This project began in the summer of 2013 with research in Seattle, Washington, and the Columbia River Gorge, Washington. In summer 2014, we conducted additional research in the Columbia River Gorge, Washington. In summer 2015, we carried out research in Bellingham, Washington.
What does APOLLO stand for?
APOLLO stands for Air Pollution On Lines... Well, the students working on the project liked the name Apollo, but we could never finish the meaning of the acronym. Even so, the name Apollo stuck. It isn't an acronym.
Research goals and experimental methods
Our research questions are:
- What is the exposure to size-segregated particulate matter (PM), both diesel PM and airborne coal dust, of people living near the rail lines?
- Can we estimate the current and potential future exposure to size-segregated PM for people living near the rail lines?
- What are the emissions from diesel trains? How do the observed emission factors compare with published data?
- Do coal trains emit coal dust into the air?
To do this, we measured size–segregated particulate matter (PM1, PM2.5 and PM10—PM less than 1 micron (µ), 2.5 µ and 10 µ in diameter, respectively), CO2 and meteorology, and used a motion–activated camera to capture video of each train for identification.
Research site locations
- Bellingham, Washington, USA
- Columbia River Gorge, between the towns of Lyle and Dallesport, Washington, USA
- Blue Ridge neighborhood in northwest Seattle, Washington, USA
- Columbia River Gorge, near Lyle, Washington, USA
Summer 2014, Columbia River Gorge, Washington:
We measured PM1, PM2.5, black carbon (BC) and CO2 during 367 train passages (train events) in the Columbia River Gorge. In four coal train events, which we call “super-dusters,” the coal dust emissions led to visible dust plumes and the highest PM2.5 concentrations observed in our study. (See the "Videos of coal trains" section below to view videos of super-dusters.) But nearly all coal trains appeared to generate some degree of coal dust (PM2.5) based on the following evidence:
- Statistically higher peak PM2.5 concentrations during passage of coal trains compared to freight trains. The PM2.5 peaks during a coal train passage are 78% higher than those during a freight train passage.
- The fact that most freight trains (52%) show a good correlation between PM2.5 and CO2, whereas very few coal trains (16%) show this relationship.
- The BC/PM2.5 fraction is statistically higher for freight trains compared to coal trains.
- The PM1/PM2.5 fraction is statistically higher during passage of freight trains compared to coal trains.
Summer 2013, Seattle and Columbia River Gorge, Washington:
We measured the PM1 emission factors for over 450 trains at two sites in Washington State and the resulting PM2.5 exposure (µgram/m3). For 84 of these trains, we also measured the black carbon emission factors. We found that:
- Living very close to the tracks in Blue Ridge increases one's exposure to diesel PM by about 6.7 µgram/m3. This level of exposure is comparable to that in the most industrial parts of Seattle (e.g., Duwamish Valley).
- There is a significant increase in large particles (>1 µm) in the air after coal trains passed by, compared with other train types. This result suggests that these trains are emitting coal dust into the atmosphere during transit.
- An increase in train traffic will increase the diesel PM exposure for residents along the rail lines. A 50% increase in rail traffic will put some neighborhoods at risk of exceeding US air quality standards.
- Diesel particulate matter and coal dust from trains in the Columbia River Gorge, Washington State, USA, by D.A. Jaffe, J. Putz, G. Hof, G. Hof, J. Hee, D.A. Lommers-Johnson, F. Gabela, J.L. Fry, B. Ayres, M. Kelp and M. Minsk, in Atmospheric Pollution Research, doi: 10.1016/j.apr.2015.04.004. Click here to read the full article.
- Diesel particulate matter emission factors and air quality implications from in-service rail in Washington State, USA, by D.A. Jaffe, G. Hof, S. Malashanka, J. Putz, J. Thayer, J.L. Fry, B. Ayres and J.R. Pierce, in Atmospheric Pollution Research 5, 344–351, doi: 10.5094/APR.2014.040. Click here to read the full article.
Videos of coal trains
These videos are of coal train events we call “super-dusters,” events with visible dust plumes and the highest PM2.5 concentrations observed in our 2014 study in the Columbia River Gorge, Washington.
- July 27, 2014, Columbia River Gorge. Click here to view the video.
- August 7, 2014, Columbia River Gorge. Click here to view the video.
- All Aboard! Three Studies on Diesel and Coal Dust from Trains in Washington State by Dan Jaffe. Click here to see the presentation slides.
- Do coal and diesel trains make for unhealthy air? by Dan Jaffe, Sofya Malashanka, Greg Hof, Jeff Thayer and Justin Putz. This presentation includes useful information for laypeople about air quality impacts on health. Click here to see the presentation slides.